My Tenant Caused a Fire: What Landlords Should Do Next
Resource Center › Landlord Problems
A kitchen fire, a dropped cigarette, an overloaded extension cord, a charging e-bike battery — most rental fires start with something a tenant did or didn’t do. When it happens, landlords face an urgent mix of safety, communication, insurance, and money questions. This guide walks through what to do, in order, and how the insurance usually works. For who pays in a tenant kitchen fire specifically, see If a Tenant Starts a Kitchen Fire, Whose Insurance Pays? as it’s added.
First Hours: Safety and Security
- Confirm everyone is safe. Check with the fire department about injuries and whether any tenants need emergency shelter. The Red Cross often assists displaced residents.
- Don’t enter until officials say it’s safe. Fire-damaged buildings can have structural, electrical, and air quality hazards.
- Secure the property. Once released by the fire department, arrange board-up, fencing, and tarps. Your policy generally expects you to protect the property from further damage, and reasonable mitigation costs are usually part of the claim.
- Get the fire report information. Note the report number and investigator’s name. The cause determination will matter for the claim and any recovery from the tenant.
Our What to Do After a Fire in Your Rental Property: A Landlord’s Complete Emergency Guide has a printable checklist.
Talk to a licensed agent
Etowah Insurance Group quotes landlord, dwelling, apartment, and condo association coverage nationwide. Tell us about the property and we will shop it with the markets that fit.
Request a Quoteor call 706-237-8319
Within a Day or Two: Report the Claim
- Call your agent and insurer promptly. Late notice can complicate a claim.
- Document everything with photos and video before cleanup.
- Gather your records: lease, rent roll, move-in inspection, and receipts for landlord-owned appliances and furnishings.
- Keep receipts for board-up, mitigation, and emergency expenses.
See How to File a Landlord Insurance Claim, Step by Step as it’s added.
How the Insurance Usually Works
Your landlord policy generally pays to repair the building and your own property, even though the tenant caused the fire, minus your deductible.
Loss of rents / fair rental value pays rent you lose while the unit is uninhabitable — if you bought it. Many budget dwelling policies leave it off.
The tenant’s renters insurance covers their belongings and additional living expenses. Its liability coverage may pay for damage the tenant negligently caused to your building.
Other tenants in a multifamily building rely on their own renters policies for belongings and temporary housing.
Subrogation: Recovering From the Tenant
After paying your claim, your insurer may pursue the tenant — or the tenant’s renters insurer — to recover what it paid, including your deductible in some cases. Cooperate with that process, and tell your insurer if the tenant has renters insurance. Check your lease for any waiver of subrogation before the claim, not after.
The Lease and the Tenant
Whether the lease ends, rent abates, or the tenant can return depends on state law and your lease. Many states allow either party to terminate when the unit is uninhabitable. Talk to a local attorney before evicting or charging the tenant, and keep communication in writing.
Rebuilding
Older buildings may need code upgrades during reconstruction — see Ordinance or Law Coverage for Rental and Apartment Buildings. Get multiple contractor estimates, keep the adjuster informed, and don’t sign assignment-of-benefits agreements without understanding them.
Preventing the Next One
- Working smoke alarms in every required location, tested at turnover
- Fire extinguishers in kitchens
- Rules on grills, candles, space heaters, and e-bike charging
- Electrical updates on older properties
- Renters insurance required in every lease
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance pay if the tenant caused the fire?
Generally yes for the building and your property, minus the deductible. The insurer may then try to recover from the tenant.
Do I still collect rent after a fire?
Usually not if the unit is uninhabitable. Loss of rents coverage replaces that income if you have it.
Should I sue the tenant myself?
Talk to your insurer first; it may pursue recovery through subrogation, including your deductible.
Does the tenant’s renters insurance pay for my building?
It may, through the tenant’s liability coverage, if the tenant was legally responsible.
Ready to compare coverage?
Send us the address, unit count, year built, and current policy (if any). A licensed agent will review it and come back with options in plain English.
Request a Quoteor call 706-237-8319
Related Guides
- Does Landlord Insurance Cover Tenant Damage?
- What to Do After a Fire in Your Rental Property: A Landlord’s Complete Emergency Guide
- What to Do After a Fire in Your Rental:The Complete Tenant's Emergency Guide
- Burst Pipe in a Rental: A Landlord's Step-by-Step Guide
- Slip-and-Fall Claim at a Rental Property: What Landlords Should Know
- Vacancy and Coverage Gaps: Protecting an Empty Rental
- A Tenant's Guest Was Injured at My Rental. Am I Liable?
- Mold Complaint or Claim at a Rental: What Landlord Insurance Covers
Browse everything in the Landlord & Apartment Insurance Resource Center, or look up a term in the insurance glossary.
This guide is general information from Etowah Insurance Group, Inc., an independent agency based in Silver Creek, Georgia. It is not legal advice, and it does not change any policy. Coverage depends on the actual policy forms, endorsements, and underwriting. State laws change; confirm current rules with your state insurance department or an attorney.

