What Happens When a Vehicle Hits Your Apartment Building? Avoiding Insurance Claim History Pitfalls
What Happens When a Vehicle Hits Your Apartment Building?
When a car crashes into your apartment building, the situation is more than just a mess to clean up—it’s an insurance minefield. If you file a claim with your own commercial property policy, it could affect your insurance premiums for the next 3 to 5 years.
This guide explains how to handle the claim through the driver’s insurance to preserve your loss history and when it might make sense to involve your building policy.
🔍 Step 1: Determine Who’s Responsible
If a vehicle strikes your apartment building, the damage should be covered by the driver’s auto liability insurance. This includes:
- Tenants, guests, or delivery drivers
- Visitors who lose control or misjudge parking
You’ll need:
- A police report
- The driver’s insurance info
- Clear photos and documentation of the damage
✅ Why You Should File Against the Driver’s Insurance
Your apartment building’s insurance policy is there for major losses, but every claim you make gets reported on your loss history report—whether it’s paid out or not.
That report is used by:
- Underwriters at renewal time
- Competing insurers when quoting
- Risk assessors when reviewing coverage limits
📌 If you can avoid filing a claim by recovering from the driver’s insurer, do it.
Doing so:
- Keeps your record clean
- Helps maintain loss-free discounts
- Avoids a deductible hit
💸 Depreciation: Why You Might Still Fall Short
Auto liability insurance (from the at-fault driver) usually pays Actual Cash Value (ACV), not Replacement Cost Value (RCV).
💡 ACV = Replacement Cost – Depreciation
Depending on the age and condition of the damaged materials, the payout might not fully cover repairs.
Examples:
- A 12-year-old exterior wall might be valued at only 40–50% of new
- A wooden railing or metal fencing could be valued at 25–30%
That shortfall becomes your problem—unless your own policy kicks in.
🔧 When to Involve Your Apartment Building’s Policy
If the ACV payout from the driver’s insurance doesn’t cover the full cost, compare it to your policy deductible.
| Scenario | Recommended Action |
|---|---|
| Full ACV covers all repairs | No claim needed on your own policy |
| Shortfall is less than deductible | Pay out-of-pocket (preserve your clean record) |
| Shortfall is greater than deductible | Consider using your RCV coverage |
Remember: RCV will reimburse you for the full cost of repairs, but only after work is completed.
⚖️ Consider These Factors Before Filing
- Driver’s insurer pays ACV only – Know the gap and whether it’s worth filing on your end.
- Policy deductible – If the shortfall is less than your deductible, filing your own claim gains you nothing and costs you everything in loss history.
- Rate impact – Some insurers charge more for any claim, not just large ones.
- Subrogation – If you must file with your policy, ask your carrier to subrogate (pursue recovery from the driver’s insurer).
🧠 Final Word: Protecting Your Record is Protecting Your Wallet
Avoiding a claim on your apartment building policy isn’t just about pride—it’s about cost control. Even a $1,000 claim can cost you tens of thousands in higher premiums over the next 3–5 years.
Whenever a vehicle causes property damage:
- Start with the driver’s insurer
- Compare losses to your deductible
- Protect your claim history when possible
Leave a Reply