NYC Files First False Claims Act Suit Against Apartment Owner, Seeking Over $10 Million
NEW YORK — November 20, 2026 — New York City announced on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that its Law Department had filed a first-of-its-kind lawsuit against apartment owner Barry Singer, seeking to force repairs and recover more than $10 million in damages and penalties. The case, filed in Bronx County Supreme Court, is the first time the city has used New York’s False Claims Act against a building owner. City officials say the complaint covers 11 apartment buildings in the Bronx and Brooklyn.
What the city alleges
According to the city’s announcement, the lawsuit accuses Singer of knowingly and improperly avoiding payment of more than $1.05 million, plus interest, that the city says is owed for emergency repair work and pest control the city performed after the owner failed to fix violations, as well as court judgments from Housing Preservation and Development proceedings and the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings. The Real Deal and Bisnow, both citing the complaint, also name another owner, Daniel Caller, and limited liability companies tied to the properties as defendants.
The city is also alleging violations of its Nuisance Abatement Law and the New York City Construction Codes. In its announcement, the Law Department said it is asking the court to compel repairs, impose civil penalties of $1,000 per day for each Nuisance Abatement Law violation, and seek treble damages and civil penalties of up to $28,619 per violation under the False Claims Act.
Bisnow, describing the filing, reported that the Singer-controlled companies had racked up about $1.06 million in debts for city-performed repairs, a figure the False Claims Act would allow the city to triple, to about $3.18 million, and that nuisance-abatement liability in the suit exceeds $8 million, for a combined demand of more than $10 million.
A new legal theory, still untested
The False Claims Act is better known as a tool against contractors or health-care providers who submit fraudulent invoices. Gothamist reported that the city’s new complaint leans on a part of the law that, officials argue, also covers a person or company that “knowingly and improperly avoids” paying money it owes. Bisnow reported that the city law dates to 2005, when it was introduced under then-Mayor Michael Bloomberg, and that this is the first time New York City has used it against property owners. The official announcement said the strategy was developed with the legal advocacy group Housing Rights Initiative.
The legal argument has not been tested in court. “To be perfectly frank, this is untested,” Department of Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Dina Levy told The Real Deal. “It’s the first time we’ve tried this and it’s super innovative. If successful, it becomes a powerful new tool, not just for Barry Singer, who has been around for decades, but for other chronically bad landlords who accrue these kinds of debts, don’t address them and don’t bring buildings into compliance.”
Levy also told The Real Deal that if the city wins, the judgment would be a “super lien” that “takes priority over the mortgage,” which she said would make it harder to sell or refinance the buildings without dealing with the city’s claim. She said HPD already has a separate open case against Singer, including a criminal contempt motion. The allegations in the new lawsuit have not been proven, and the defendants have not yet had their day in court. Gothamist reported that Singer did not respond to a phone message left with his attorney.
Conditions cited at two Bronx buildings
The city’s announcement highlighted two Bronx properties as examples of the conditions described in the complaint:
- 2500 Webb Avenue. The city said the building has 456 violations, including 183 classified as immediately hazardous. It described the facade as an “immediate hazard” with “potential to collapse,” and cited inadequate pedestrian protection and an obstructed fire escape. Gothamist reported that the building has 58 apartments.
- 3030 Heath Avenue. The city said the building has been under a full vacate order since a four-alarm fire on Jan. 15, 2025, and that the owner has not complied with orders to repair the damage. Conditions listed include missing sections of the roof, water damage, missing windows, a partially collapsed loft area and problems with gas valves. The city counted 261 violations there, including 105 classified as immediately hazardous.
The Real Deal reported that Singer held the top spot on the Public Advocate’s annual “worst landlord list” in 2024, when his portfolio had nearly 2,900 open HPD violations, and ranked third on last year’s list with 15 buildings. Gothamist also described him as third on the most recent roster.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said, “When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants.” Corporation Counsel Steven Banks called the False Claims Act “a powerful new tool to seek relief for tenants and hold landlords accountable for the public nuisances they have created in our communities.”
What it could mean for apartment owners’ insurance and risk
This case is one lawsuit against a specific owner and related companies, and a court has not yet ruled on the city’s new legal theory. Even so, apartment owners should pay attention to the risk it is trying to create. If the approach holds up, unpaid emergency-repair bills, outstanding OATH or court judgments, and long-running hazardous code violations could be treated as False Claims Act exposure, with treble damages and daily nuisance penalties on top of ordinary housing-court or administrative fines. Levy’s “super lien” comment, if the city prevails, also points to a financing and sale problem, not just a code-enforcement one.
A practical step is to treat open, immediately hazardous violations and any unpaid city repair charges or judgments as issues to close promptly, and to keep clear records of repairs, permits and payments. Ask your insurance agent how your current liability program would respond if a tenant were injured because of a maintenance or habitability condition. Whether a policy would respond to government fines, penalties or unpaid repair assessments is a separate question that varies by form and endorsement; do not assume a standard general liability policy will pay those amounts. For a refresher on how landlord liability coverage generally works, see our guide to landlord liability insurance.
This article is news, not legal advice. Owners with questions about a specific building or citation should talk with their own attorney and insurance agent.
Sources
- Gothamist, “Mamdani tests new strategy to punish bad NYC landlords in latest lawsuit,” Nov. 18, 2026: gothamist.com
- News 12 Brooklyn, “Mamdani announces filing of unprecedented lawsuit against neglectful NYC landlord,” Nov. 18, 2026: brooklyn.news12.com
- The Real Deal, “Mamdani pulls new legal lever in landlord crackdown,” Nov. 19, 2026: therealdeal.com
- Bisnow, “Mamdani Admin Sues Bronx Landlords, Claiming Unpaid Fines Amount To Fraud,” Nov. 18, 2026: bisnow.com
- NYC Mayor’s Office, “Mamdani Administration Takes Notoriously Noncompliant Landlord to Court in First-of-Its-Kind Lawsuit, Seeks More Than $10 Million,” Nov. 18, 2026: nyc.gov
- NYC Law Department, same announcement, Nov. 18, 2026: nyc.gov/site/law


Leave a Reply