Workers on a construction site

Insuring a BRRRR Property Through Each Phase

Resource Center › Investor Guides

BRRRR — buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat — is a popular strategy for building a rental portfolio. It also moves a property through several very different insurance risks in a matter of months. The investors who get burned are usually the ones who keep one policy through all of it. Here’s how to insure each phase. For the strategy itself, see The BRRRR Method Explained.

Phase 1: Buy

BRRRR properties are often distressed, vacant, or both. A standard landlord policy written for an occupied rental may not fit:

  • Vacant at closing? Ask for a vacant dwelling or renovation policy rather than a standard landlord form.
  • Lender requirements. Hard-money and bridge lenders typically require property coverage, the lender named as mortgagee, and sometimes liability. Get their requirements in writing before closing.
  • Value. Insure to the cost to rebuild — not the low purchase price — or you may be badly underinsured if the house burns mid-rehab.

Talk to a licensed agent

Etowah Insurance Group quotes landlord, dwelling, apartment, and condo association coverage nationwide. Tell us about the property and we will shop it with the markets that fit.

Request a Quoteor call 706-237-8319

Phase 2: Rehab

During renovation, the main exposures are fire, theft of materials and appliances, vandalism, water damage from open plumbing, and injuries to contractors and visitors.

  • Builders risk or renovation coverage covers the building as it’s improved and materials on site. Some vacant policies don’t. See Builder’s Risk vs. Vacant Property Policy During a Rehab.
  • Completed value. The limit should reflect the after-repair rebuild cost.
  • Contractors. Collect certificates of general liability and workers compensation; ask to be named an additional insured.
  • Liability for the owner, even when the contractor has its own.

See Vacant Building & Renovation Insurance for Rental Properties.

Phase 3: Rent

The moment a tenant signs a lease, switch to a landlord policy:

  • DP-3 or equivalent for the building at replacement cost
  • Liability endorsement or policy
  • Loss of rents / fair rental value
  • Water backup and ordinance or law as appropriate

Bind the landlord policy before move-in so there’s no gap. Require renters insurance in the lease.

Phase 4: Refinance

Refinance lenders — including DSCR lenders — have their own insurance requirements: replacement cost, specified deductibles, rent loss coverage, flood in mapped zones, and the new lender as mortgagee. Update the mortgagee clause at closing. See Insurance Requirements for DSCR Loan Rental Properties.

Phase 5: Repeat

As you add properties, consider moving to a portfolio policy and an umbrella. See Insuring Multiple Rental Properties: Portfolio and Blanket Policies.

Common BRRRR Insurance Mistakes

  • Keeping a vacant or builders risk policy after a tenant moves in
  • Leaving a landlord policy on a gutted house
  • Insuring to purchase price instead of rebuild cost
  • Forgetting to update the mortgagee after refinance
  • Titling the property in an LLC but insuring it personally

Frequently Asked Questions

Can one policy cover all BRRRR phases?

Some specialty programs transition from renovation to occupied coverage, but many investors need separate policies for each phase.

Do I need builders risk for a cosmetic rehab?

Not always. Light rehabs on occupied or briefly vacant homes may stay on a landlord policy with the insurer’s agreement. Major renovations usually need renovation or builders risk coverage.

When should I switch to a landlord policy?

Before the tenant moves in.

Ready to compare coverage?

Send us the address, unit count, year built, and current policy (if any). A licensed agent will review it and come back with options in plain English.

Request a Quoteor call 706-237-8319

Related Guides

Browse everything in the Landlord & Apartment Insurance Resource Center, or look up a term in the insurance glossary.

This guide is general information from Etowah Insurance Group, Inc., an independent agency based in Silver Creek, Georgia. It is not legal advice, and it does not change any policy. Coverage depends on the actual policy forms, endorsements, and underwriting. State laws change; confirm current rules with your state insurance department or an attorney.