Insurance to Value and Coinsurance: What Apartment Building Owners Need to Know
If you own an apartment building, having the right insurance coverage is more than just a checkbox — it’s a key part of protecting your livelihood. But even with a policy in place, there’s a critical detail that often gets overlooked: how much coverage you actually have compared to what you really need.
This article explains why making sure your building is insured for its full worth is so important — and what kind of financial hit you could face if it’s not. We’ll walk through the idea of undercoverage, how insurance companies share responsibility for losses, and what can happen when you’re not carrying your fair share.
What Does It Mean to Be “Insured to Value”?
In plain terms, being “insured to value” means that your insurance policy reflects what it would cost to rebuild your apartment complex today — not what you paid for it years ago, or what it might sell for on the open market.
That rebuilding cost includes materials, labor, permits, and code updates. It’s a figure that changes over time due to inflation, supply costs, and regional construction trends.
Think of it like replacing a car — you wouldn’t expect a payout based on the sticker price from ten years ago. The same logic applies to buildings.
Understanding the Hidden Clause: Shared Risk and Minimum Coverage
Most commercial property policies include a built-in expectation: if you want the insurance company to fully back you during a loss, you need to carry a certain amount of coverage — often around 80% to 100% of what it would cost to rebuild the structure.
If you fall short of that minimum, the insurance company reduces how much they’ll pay out — even if the damage is only partial.
This arrangement is based on the principle of shared risk. You’re expected to carry your portion of the load by keeping your coverage amount high enough. If you don’t, you’re essentially shortchanging the agreement, and the insurer will scale back their share in response.
A Real-World Example
Let’s say you own a mid-sized apartment building.
- It would take $2,000,000 to rebuild the entire structure today.
- Your policy requires you to carry 80% of that figure — or $1,600,000.
- But your current policy only covers $1,200,000.
- Then a kitchen fire causes $500,000 in damages.
Because you’re only carrying 75% of the required coverage (1.2M / 1.6M), the insurer says, “We’ll only pay 75% of the loss.” So instead of covering the full $500,000, they cover $375,000. After a deductible of $10,000, you walk away with just $365,000.
That’s a $135,000 gap — all because the building wasn’t fully covered to match its current worth.
How to Make Sure You’re Covered Correctly
Avoiding this kind of shortfall isn’t complicated, but it does take some upkeep. Here are some practical steps:
- Update Your Building’s Value Regularly
Construction costs shift over time. Work with professionals who can give you a realistic number — not just a guess or outdated estimate. - Revisit Your Policy at Least Once a Year
If you’ve made upgrades, finished renovations, or noticed rising material prices, it’s time to refresh your coverage amounts. - Ask About Waivers or Exceptions
Some insurers offer special agreements where they won’t penalize you if the value was agreed upon in advance. This can simplify your planning. - Talk to Someone Who Knows the Landscape
Insurance advisors who understand commercial real estate can help make sure you’re not leaving anything on the table.
Final Thoughts
Owning an apartment building is a serious investment — one that deserves serious protection. Having a policy isn’t enough if it’s based on outdated numbers or doesn’t reflect what it would truly cost to start over.
Don’t let a technical clause or a gap in coverage turn a minor disaster into a financial crisis. By keeping your coverage in sync with your building’s real-world value, you’re not just protecting your property — you’re preserving your long-term financial health.
Leave a Reply